Published on 19 December 2019 in Client Alerts

Breakfast Seminar: Financing and Debt Instruments: Often Overlooked Issues of Public International Law”

The first speaker was Ms Penelope Nevill, a distinguished barrister at Twenty Essex Chambers.  With an emphasis on English law and international law, Ms Nevill discussed how debt obligations and contracts might be affected by the existence of armed conflict and the UK and EU sanctions regime.  Her discussion explained the principles that underlie the Trading with the Enemy Act, the relevant rules of the international law of armed conflict and the common law doctrines of illegality, frustration and impossibility.  Ms Nevill also discussed recent cases such as Law Debenture Trust Corporation v Ukraine [2019] QB 1121 (CA), Lamesa Investment Limited v Cynergy Bank Limited [2019] EWHC 1877 (Comm), Ministry of Defence v IMS Ltd [2019] 1 WLR 6409 and investor-State arbitrations brought against Russia for its activities in Crimea.

The second speaker was Dr Maria Fogdestam-Agius, a lawyer at Volterra Fietta.  Dr Fogdestam-Agius’s presentation can be found 21 minutes and 16 seconds into the recording.  She described the risks that claims arising out of international human rights law might create for financial institutions, even when the financial institutions do not have operational control of the underlying borrower.  This included a discussion of human rights-related class action lawsuits before North American and European courts, as well as EU directives and domestic laws that require certain institutions to adopt international standards of human rights due diligence and non-financial reporting requirements.  Dr Fogdestam-Agius concluded with specific recommendations for how financial institutions can reduce the risk of reputational and other injuries arising out of claims based on international human rights.

The third speaker was Mr Gunjan Sharma, a lawyer at Volterra Fietta.  Mr Sharma’s presentation can be found 40 minutes and 25 seconds into the recording.  Mr Sharma discussed the negotiating dynamics in play when international organisations make longer-term or recurring financing commitments to borrowers but still seek to preserve the full extent of charter immunity.  Using jurisdiction and venue clauses often found in agreements with the International Finance Corporation as an example, Mr Sharma explained the issues raised for borrowers who want a forum to enforce an international organisation’s contractual lending commitments in the face of the organisation’s broad assertion of immunity.  Mr Sharma concluded by asking a question:  given the ambiguity as to whether debtor actions are precluded by the charter immunity of some international organisations, might international organisations and borrowers both benefit from including limited forum selection clauses and limited waivers of immunity in borrowing agreements?

 

For further information about this seminar and other issues related to public international law and financing, please contact Robert G. Volterra, Gunjan Sharma or Maria Fogdestam-Agius at info@volterrafietta.com.

More Client Alerts

| Client Alerts

Publication of Law Over Borders: Arbitration Guide, edited by Volterra Fietta Partners Ahmed Abdel-Hakam, Gunjan Sharma and Robert G Volterra

The second edition of the “Law over borders: Arbitration Guide” has been released by the publishers. The Guide is edited by Volterra Fietta Partners Robert G Volterra, Gunjan Sharma and Ahmed Abdel-Hakam.

Learn more

| Client Alerts

Revamping India’s Model Bilateral Investment Treaty

Nearly ten years after its 2015 Model Bilateral Investment Treaty was released, India is now set again to revamp its approach to bilateral investment treaties (“BITs”) – this time, in order better to attract and incentivise inbound foreign investment. 

Learn more

| Client Alerts

International Maritime Organization approves new net-zero regulations for global shipping

In April 2025, after nearly 10 years of negotiations, the International Maritime Organization (the “IMO”) approved new net-zero regulations for global shipping.

Learn more

| Client Alerts

Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania set to become first States to exit global land mines treaty

Between April and June 2025, the Parliaments of Estonia, Finland, Latvia and Lithuania each voted to approve their country’s exits from the 1997 Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction (the “Ottawa Convention”).

Learn more
View all