Published on 4 August 2017 in Client Alerts

PCA designates appointing authority in an investment case against Libya under the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation Investment Agreement

 On 27 March 2017, the Secretary-General of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (the “PCA”) designated an appointing authority in the investment arbitration between United Arab Emirates-based company DS Construction FZCO and Libya under the Agreement on promotion, protection and guarantee of investments among member States of the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (the “OIC Investment Agreement”).  The PCA’s designation breaks a stalemate caused by the failure of Libya to appoint an arbitrator and the subsequent failure of the Secretary-General of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (the “OIC”) to appoint the arbitrator on behalf of Libya.  The designation was made in accordance with the 1976 Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (“UNCITRAL”), which allow a party to the proceedings to request the Secretary-General of the PCA to designate a new appointing authority when the other party and an appointing authority previously designated fail to appoint an arbitrator.  The Secretary-General of the PCA designated as appointing authority on behalf of Libya French professor and arbitrator Pierre-Marie Dupuy.  Professor Dupuy appointed Mr Nassib Ziade, former ICSID Deputy Secretary-General.  Mr Ziade and the claimant’s appointee, Mr Stanimir Alexandrov, subsequently appointed Judge Bruno Simma—a former Judge of the International Court of Justice—as chairman of the arbitral tribunal.

The investment arbitration initiated by DS Construction FZCO against Libya in October 2016 arises out of a dispute involving claimant’s investments in the construction sector in Libya.  The OIC Investment Agreement provides for ad hoc arbitration between investors and states, without any reference to the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules.  However, the claimant reportedly succeeded in arguing that the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules—which are applicable under the Austria – Libya Bilateral Investment Treaty—also apply to arbitral proceedings under the OIC Investment Agreement by virtue of the operation of the Most-Favoured Nation clause contained in the latter instrument.

The PCA’s designation of an appointing authority in the arbitration between DS Construction FZCO and Libya could have significant consequences for other arbitral proceedings under the OIC Investment Agreement.  Claimants in other investment arbitral proceedings under the OIC Investment Agreement could be entitled to request the PCA Secretary-General to designate an appointing authority, if the respondent States and the OIC Secretary-General fail to appoint arbitrators.

More Client Alerts

| Client Alerts

Lithuania institutes proceedings against Belarus before the International Court of Justice over the smuggling of migrants

On 19 May 2025, the Republic of Lithuania filed an Application instituting proceedings against the Republic of Belarus before the International Court of Justice.

Learn more

| Client Alerts

France institutes proceedings against Iran before the International Court of Justice over detained citizens

On 16 May 2025, the French Republic filed an Application instituting proceedings against the Islamic Republic of Iran before the International Court of Justice.

Learn more

| Client Alerts, Events

Volterra Fietta hosts commercial disputes seminar on the “Impacts of Tariffs on Supply Contracts: Key Legal Issues”

On 16 April 2025, Volterra Fietta held a virtual seminar entitled “Impacts of Tariffs on Supply Contracts: Key Legal Issues”.

Learn more

| Client Alerts

Ahmed Abdel Hakam speaks on panel with the Secretary General of the Arbitration Centre of the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (“OIC”) during Paris Arbitration Week 2025

On 11 April 2025, Volterra Fietta Partner Ahmed Abdel Hakam spoke at a seminar hosted by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation Arbitration Centre (“OIC”) during Paris Arbitration Week 2025.  The topic of the seminar was “Bridging the Gap: Streamlining Dispute Resolution for Investment and Trade in the OIC Member States”.

Learn more
View all